Keyboard shortcuts

Press or to navigate between chapters

Press S or / to search in the book

Press ? to show this help

Press Esc to hide this help

Annotating Nouns and Pronouns

So far, we have only looked at verbal predicates. But nouns can have (core) arguments too. Specifically, this is true for event nouns and relational nouns.

Event nouns are annotated much like verbs:

Dependency graph for sentence: Kim ’s breaking of the vase. Token breaking is labeled INTERNAL-STATE-INIT and has an edge labeled CAUSER to token Kim and an edge labeled has-state to token vase. Dependency graph for sentence: Kim ’s height. Token height is labeled PROPERTY and has an edge labeled has-property to token Kim. Dependency graph for sentence: Sandy ’s destruction. Token destruction is labeled EXISTENCE-DEINIT and has an edge labeled existent to token Sandy. Dependency graph for sentence: Sandy ’s destruction of the city. Token destruction is labeled EXISTENCE-DEINIT and has an edge labeled CAUSER to token Sandy and an edge labeled existent to token city.

Relational nouns are not much different, except that they additionally refer to one of the participants in the relation. But we are only concerned with evocation, not with reference.

Dependency graph for sentence: Kim ’s friend. Token friend is labeled SOCIAL-RELATION and has an edge labeled socially-related to token Kim. Dependency graph for sentence: my critic. Token critic is labeled EVALUATION and has an edge labeled evaluee to token my.

When used in predicative function in copula clauses, relational nouns assign a role to the subject:

Dependency graph for sentence: He is our physics teacher. Token teacher is labeled MESSAGE-HABIT and has an edge labeled SENDER to token He and an edge labeled EXPERIENCER to token our and an edge labeled topic to token physics. Dependency graph for sentence: She is the president of our club. Token president is labeled BOND and has an edge labeled tied to token She and an edge labeled tied-to to token club. Dependency graph for sentence: Sandy is the destroyer of the city. Token destroyer is labeled EXISTENCE-DEINIT and has an edge labeled CAUSER to token Sandy and an edge labeled existent to token city.

Many nouns, of course, are neither event nouns nor relational nouns, and thus do not have any (core) arguments. The includes proper nouns and is also true for most pronouns. Thus, the rule that we mentioned earlier applies: an occurrence of a predicate without any core arguments is always annotated with the special superframe ENTITY.

Dependency graph for sentence: a tree. Token tree is labeled ENTITY. Dependency graph for sentence: Kim. Token Kim is labeled ENTITY. Dependency graph for sentence: they. Token they is labeled ENTITY.

Occasionally, pronouns do have arguments. In that case, frame them like you would the antecedent:

Dependency graph for sentence: The picture was that of the boa. Token that is labeled MESSAGE and has an edge labeled SAME to token picture and an edge labeled topic to token boa. Dependency graph for sentence: This asteroid has only once been seen through the telescope . That was by a Turkish astronomer , in 1909 .. Token That is labeled EXPERIENCE and has an edge labeled experiencer to token astronomer. Token astronomer is labeled ENTITY and has an edge labeled SCENE to token That and an edge labeled SCENE to token Turkish and an edge labeled TIME to token 1909.

When used with a non-event, non-relational noun, the copula construction assigns INSTANCE to the subject if predicative, and SAME if equational (cf. Stassen 1997, p. 100–6; Croft 2022, § 10.1.2):

Dependency graph for sentence: It was a picture of a boa constrictor. Token picture is labeled MESSAGE and has an edge labeled INSTANCE to token It and an edge labeled topic to token boa. Dependency graph for sentence: Baobabs were not little bushes. Token bushes is labeled ENTITY and has an edge labeled INSTANCE to token Baobabs and an edge labeled SCENE to token little. Dependency graph for sentence: The planet from which the little prince came is the asteroid known as B-612. Token asteroid is labeled ENTITY and has an edge labeled SAME to token planet and an edge labeled SCENE to token known.

With adpositions, the copula construction can assign different roles still:

Dependency graph for sentence: the sprout was not like any other small sprouts on his planet. Token sprouts is labeled ENTITY and has an edge labeled COMPARED to token sprout and an edge labeled SCENE to token not and an edge labeled SCENE to token small and an edge labeled LOCATION to token planet.